Decision Criteria
Editorial decisions at the Journal of Emerging Intelligent Engineering Research and Technology (JEIERT) are based on the overall scholarly, scientific, technical, and ethical quality of the submitted manuscript. The following key criteria are considered during editorial assessment and peer review:
Originality and Novelty
The manuscript should present original research, innovative methods, new findings, improved techniques, or meaningful advancements relevant to engineering, technology, or applied sciences.
Technical and Scientific Quality
The research methodology, experimental design, system architecture, analytical procedures, implementation, validation, and interpretation of results should be technically sound and scientifically appropriate.
Relevance to Journal Scope
The manuscript must be relevant to the aims and scope of JEIERT and should contribute to engineering, intelligent technologies, applied sciences, or related interdisciplinary research areas.
Clarity and Coherence
The manuscript should be clearly written, logically structured, and professionally presented. The objectives, methodology, results, discussion, and conclusions should be coherent and easy to follow.
Significance and Impact
The study should demonstrate meaningful academic, scientific, engineering, technological, industrial, or societal significance. Preference is given to research that advances current knowledge, addresses important problems, improves existing technologies, or offers useful applications.
Ethical and Research Integrity
Manuscripts must comply with JEIERT's ethical guidelines and publication policies. Plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, inappropriate manipulation of data or images, duplicate publication, undisclosed conflicts of interest, and other forms of research misconduct are not acceptable.
Decision Categories
Accept: The manuscript is suitable for publication and requires no further substantive revision.
Minor Revision: The manuscript requires limited corrections or clarification before it can be considered for acceptance.
Major Revision: Significant modifications, additional analysis, clarification, experiments, validation, or restructuring are required before the manuscript can be reconsidered.
Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's requirements for originality, technical quality, relevance, ethical standards, or publication suitability in its current form.
Final publication decisions are made by the editorial team after considering reviewer reports, author responses, manuscript revisions, and the overall suitability of the work for JEIERT.